How Not to Do Email Marketing (And Why I’m Hitting Report Spam)
Approximate length: 1,280 words
Estimated reading time: about 6 minutes (or about three days’ worth of “just bumping this up” emails)
Key Takeaways:
- Unsolicited pitches with relentless follow-ups damage trust and your sender reputation.
- “Reply ‘No thanks'” shifts your sales work onto the recipient. Most will hit Report spam instead.
- Connect-and-pitch DMs on social media are the same problem in a different inbox.
- In Canada, CASL generally requires consent, sender ID and an unsubscribe option for commercial emails.
- Build relationships first: be helpful, grow an opt-in list and give more than you ask.
Dozens of strangers want to "help" me every single day
Every morning I open my inbox to a fresh batch of people who want to fix my business. More clients. A better website (yes, really, I build websites). Google Ads. Facebook Ads. A “strategic partnership.” A guest post swap. A done-for-you lead generation system that will fill my calendar by Friday.
I have never met these people. We have never corresponded. I haven’t liked their posts, subscribed to their newsletter, downloaded their freebie, or even stumbled across their website. They simply appeared, fully convinced that what I need most in life is them.
So let’s talk about how NOT to do email marketing. Because if you run a small business and you are tempted to try this approach, I would love to save you the time, the reputation damage and possibly a fine.
The anatomy of a cold pitch (you'll recognize it)
These emails follow a pattern so predictable I could write them in my sleep.
- It arrives out of nowhere. Sometimes from a Gmail address, sometimes from a domain. Either way, it isn’t coming through a proper email marketing platform with an unsubscribe link. It’s sent straight to me like we’re old friends.
- It’s “personalized.” My first name and maybe my business name are dropped in. That’s the extent of the research.
- It promises the moon. Double your leads. Rank #1 on Google. A flood of new clients in 30 days.
- It follows up. Relentlessly. Ignore it and the sequel arrives: “Just bumping this to the top of your inbox.” Then: “In case you didn’t see this.” Then: “Should I close your file?”.
- It ends with the P.S. “If this isn’t relevant, just reply ‘No thanks.’
That last one deserves its own moment. Replying confirms my address is active and monitored, which often earns me more email. And it puts the job of managing their sales pipeline on me.
I didn’t sign up for that job. I’m not replying. I’m hitting “Report spam.”
Social media has its own version: the connect-and-pitch
It isn’t just email. On LinkedIn, Facebook and Instagram, it goes like this:
- You get a connection request from someone you don’t know. Fine. Networking is the point.
- You accept.
- Within minutes, a DM lands: “Thanks for connecting! I help women entrepreneurs scale to six figures. I have three spots left in my group program. Would you like to hop on a quick call?”
We have been connected for less time than it takes to boil a kettle. They haven’t read a single post of mine. They don’t know what I do, who I serve or whether I’m already at six figures, five figures, or happily retired-in-training.
It’s the networking equivalent of walking into a business mixer, shaking someone’s hand and asking them to sign a contract before letting go.
It’s icky. And it makes me think twice about accepting the next request.
Why this approach backfires
It tells me exactly how you’ll treat me as a client. If your first move is to ignore my boundaries and keep pushing when I don’t answer, I can only imagine what working together looks like. You’ve shown me your customer service before I’ve spent a dime.
It trains inboxes to bury you. Every “Report spam” click teaches Gmail and Outlook that your domain sends junk. Do that enough and even your legitimate emails to real clients start landing in spam folders.
In Canada, it can break the law. Canada’s Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL) generally requires consent before you send a commercial electronic message, plus clear identification of who you are and a working unsubscribe option. Penalties can reach up to $10 million per violation for businesses.
Some senders lean on the “I found your email online” defence. CASL does allow implied consent when someone has conspicuously published their address, but the CRTC has said that public availability alone is not a broad licence to contact any address you find. The message must also be relevant to the person’s business role, and the address can’t be posted with a “no unsolicited messages” note. It’s a narrow exception, not a loophole.
I’m not a lawyer (I just play one online – lol, just kidding). If you’re planning any outreach to Canadians, read up on CASL or ask someone who is.
What to do instead: earn the yes
Good marketing is more like a friendship than a sales call. Nobody proposes on the first date. Here’s what actually builds trust.
- Show up where your people are, and be useful. Comment thoughtfully on their posts. Answer questions in groups. Share tips without a sales link attached. Let people get to know you before you ask for anything.
- Build a list of people who chose you. Offer a genuinely helpful freebie, newsletter or checklist and let people opt in. A list of 200 people who want to hear from you beats 20,000 strangers who don’t.
- Use a real email platform. Tools like MailerLite or ActiveCampaign handle consent, unsubscribe links and sender details for you, and they protect your domain’s reputation.
- Give more than you ask. A good rule of thumb: several helpful emails or posts for every one that sells. When you do make an offer, it lands with people who already trust you.
- If you must reach out cold, do your homework. Make it one-to-one, specific and relevant to what that person actually does. Reference something real. Ask a question instead of pitching. And if they don’t reply, take the hint. Silence is an answer.
- On social, connect to connect. After someone accepts, say hello, ask what they’re working on, and then stop. Engage with their content for a while. If there’s a fit, it will become obvious to both of you.
The difference is consent and context. Marketing people asked for feels like help. Marketing they didn’t ask for feels like a stranger with their foot in your door.
The bottom line
I’m not against email marketing. I love it. I send my own Tuesday Tech Tip (and other emails) weekly to people who signed up for it. That’s the whole point: they signed up.
What I’m against is treating strangers like a list to be mined. If that’s how you start a relationship, I’m going to assume that’s how you run your business, and I’m going to treat your message exactly like what it is.
If you’d like help building an email list and website that attract the right people (no spam folder required), let’s chat.
And yes, you reached out to me. That’s how it should work.

Cyndi Fleming-Alton
Cyndi is the founder of Digital Chicks and has spent 20 years helping mission-driven entrepreneurs build sustainable revenue and create meaningful impact.
Endlessly curious (and proudly interdisciplinary), she holds degrees in Computer Science, Human Resources, Emergency Management, and Information Privacy - balanced with studies in Reiki, Sound Therapy, and Meditation. Her work spans all levels of Canadian government, healthcare, and the private sector in IT and communications, including a year in Africa as a research coordinator and photographer.
A lifelong digital nomad, Cyndi has lived and worked in several countries and now calls Ontario, Canada home, where she enjoys a slightly hippie lifestyle with her partner and an assortment of four-legged co-workers.